What is the difference between direct primary care (DPC) and concierge “boutique” medicine?
Direct primary care (DPC) and concierge “boutique” medicine are both membership-based healthcare models that emphasize a closer doctor-patient relationship and improved access to care. There are, however, key differences between the two models.
DPC VS. CONCIERGE MEDICINE
PAYMENT STRUCTURE
DPC
-
Flat Fee: Patients pay a flat monthly, quarterly, or annual fee directly to their primary care doctor. This fee typically covers the majority of primary care services done in the clinic and gives patients easier access to their doctor, including urgent needs outside of business hours.
-
No Insurance Billing: DPC practices do not bill insurance for services provided.
CONCIERGE MEDICINE
-
Membership Fee: Patients pay an annual membership fee for enhanced access to their physician and extra conveniences.
-
Insurance Billing: In addition to the membership fee, concierge practices still bill insurance for services provided.
-
The membership fee simply covers the 'enhanced access' to their doctor.​
COST
DPC
-
Lower Fees: DPC membership fees are usually lower than those in concierge medicine, often ranging from $50 to $200 per month.
-
Predictable and Transparent: The fee usually includes unlimited office visits, telemedicine (phone, video, email), basic in-office labs, in-office procedures, and gives all patients access to low-cost labs. This allows patients to better predict their annual healthcare dollars.
CONCIERGE MEDICINE
-
Higher Fees: Concierge medicine fees are typically higher, often ranging from $250 to $750 per month.
-
Additional Costs: Patients will still be charged copays, deductibles and co-insurances in addition to in-office studies, labs and procedures.
PHILOSOPHY
DPC
-
Enhanced Service: Concierge medicine focuses on providing enhanced services with greater conveniences, often including 24/7 access to the physician.
CONCIERGE MEDICINE
-
Access and Affordability: DPC aims to provide affordable and accessible primary care by reducing insurance, government, and pharmaceutical industry interference. Instead, the direct primary care physician focuses on strengthening the doctor-patient relationship.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
HOW DO DPC AND CONCIERGE MEDICINE COMPARE?
DIFFERENCES
​​
COST STRUCTURE​
-
DPC: Generally lower membership fee covering a wide array of primary care services and cost is more predictable. Patients have access to low cost labs or can choose to use their insurance for lab fees.
-
Concierge Medicine: Typical insurance billing and generally a higher membership fee for patients to have 24/7 access to their doctor and have extra conveniences.
SERVICE FOCUS​
-
DPC: Emphasizes affordability and accessibility with a straightforward service model.
-
Concierge Medicine: Emphasizes luxury and extensive physician access.
SIMILARITIES
​​
-
Both models aim to improve the quality of primary care by enhancing the doctor-patient relationship, reducing patient load, and providing more personalized care.
-
Both offer benefits like same-day or next-day appointments, longer consultation times, and better overall patient satisfaction compared to typical insurance-based primary care models.
-
In summary, while both DPC and concierge medicine offer membership-based care, DPC focuses on affordability and easier access, whereas concierge medicine offers a higher level of accessibility and personalized care in addition to billing insurance.
MEDICAL SCENARIO #1
48 48-year-old gentleman with a strange sensation yesterday of heart racing and mild difficulty catching his breath. He has health insurance and has not paid anything into his $1000 deductible
DPC ($100/month)
​
Patient was able to schedule an office visit the next day. His office visit cost $0. His EKG cost $0. The doctor recommends a chest x-ray and some labs. Since he hasn’t met his deductible, the patient chooses to use the DPC contracted prices for labs which is a total of $75. He also decides to pay for his chest x-ray without insurance and it costs $50. He has a follow-up appointment in 1 week to discuss results which costs $0.
​
Total cost: $225 ($100 for the monthly membership + $75 for labs + $50 for a chest x-ray)
Concierge ($250/month)
​
Patient was able to schedule an office visit the next day. His office visit cost $150 (insurance contracted rate goes towards his deductible). His EKG cost $100 (insurance contracted rate goes towards his deductible). The doctor recommends a chest x-ray and some labs (insurance contracted rate $750 total and it goes towards his deductible. He has a follow-up appointment in 1 week to discuss results which costs $35 (copay for PCP visit after deductible met).
​
Total cost: $1285 ($250 for the monthly membership + $150 for the office visit + $100 for the EKG + $450 for labs + $300 for a chest x-ray + $35 copay for follow-up visit)
MEDICAL SCENARIO #2
12 y/o girl with a severe sore throat. Mother is concerned about strep. The family has already met the deductible. Mother can’t get off work until 5 pm to bring the patient in for evaluation.
DPC ($50/MONTH)
​
Mother was offered a same-day appointment at 3 pm or the next day at 9 am. She was seen the next day at 9 am. Her office visit cost was $0. Her rapid strep test was $0.
​
​Total cost: $50 ($50 for the monthly membership + $0 for in-office lab)
CONCIERGE ($250/MONTH)
​
Mother was able to schedule a same-day appointment at 6 pm. Her office visit cost $35 (copay). Her rapid strep cost $25 (insurance contracted rate).
Total cost: $310 ($250 for the monthly membership + $35 for the copay + $25 for the rapid strep test)